The Apple And The Arrow
See a Problem?
Thanks for telling us almost the trouble.
Friend Reviews
Community Reviews
However, and this is indeed a very very big however for me personally, I just have not found either the storytelling or even the general themes of
The Apple and the Arrow all that peculiarly European, all that especially Swiss in nature (except for possibly Conrad Vitrify's accompanying illustrations), with the full general plot line reading more similar a Northward American (a Usa) story of a unmarried and mettlesome patriot fighting against oppressive tyranny (albeit of course painted with and in a thin and pale cracking veneer of Switzerland).For according to my own understanding of the Wilhelm Tell legend (and how Wilhelm Tell is too portrayed in Friedrich Schiller's famous play on the latter, how he is featured in Schiller's vivid 1804 drama
Wilhelm Tell), Wilhelm Tell is really and mostly NOT as he is for the nearly role portrayed by the Buffs as right from the Showtime of The Apple and the Pointer being an active conspirator against Gessler and Habsburg authority (no, Tell has generally or at to the lowest degree more often than not been portrayed both historically, folklorically and in European literature every bit someone who is at offset rather an aloof and coolheaded loner, who although sympathetic to the rebellion against Republic of austria, confronting Habsburg, is more concerned with his personal freedom equally a solitary mountain huntsman and only decides to actively and wholly join in the rebellion against Austrian rule when Gessler basically and without pardon and mercy forces his manus with the apple/arrow incident).And even the apple/pointer incident (the master turning betoken of the legend and folklore regarding Wilhelm Tell equally a hero, as a Swiss patriot) has not actually (at to the lowest degree according to my knowledge of the Tell legend) been portrayed all that much in fable and literature as the Buffs have depicted it in
The Apple and the Pointer (for unlike in the latter novel, in both Schiller's Wilhelm Tell and in nigh of the folktales, the legends surrounding Wilhelm Tell equally a hero of the Swiss confederacy, Tell does non in fact actively and verbosely refuse to kneel earlier Gessler's plumed hat, that his failure to bow earlier it in respect might in fact take even been, as Tell attempts to explain to Gessler in Schiller'south play, an actual oversight on his function, an unintentional omission). Of course, in both Schiller's Wilhelm Tell and in Mary and Conrad Vitrify's The Apple and the Arrow the entire premise of forcing the Swiss to admit Gessler'due south tyrannical authorisation by having them salute and bow before his chapeau is considered and presented every bit being totally and utterly anathema, and the end event is also and indeed similar, is in fact the same, with Tell not bowing in front of the lid and then being forced to shoot an apple from his son Walter's head, and then later assassinating Gessler in Küssnacht (and why Tell does non immediately shoot Gessler and actually engages in the now famous "apple tree-shot" I have also never really and fully understood).But yes, how Wilhelm Tell is portrayed as a general literary character in
The Apple and the Arrow, does indeed bother me more than a bit on a personal level, as his presentation as a rather raging and right from the start agile conspirator against Gessler and Habsburg tyranny is so majorly different from the Wilhelm Tell of history and legend that I know and yes love (from both Swiss folklore to Friedrich Schiller'south classic play), that I cannot really, that I have not actually been able merely to read and simply enjoy The Apple and the Arrow, and that the to me a bit erroneous depictions of peculiarly Wilhelm Tell's character practise get out more a bit to be personally desired. And thus for me, only a ii star rating for The Apple and the Arrow (and no, not a terrible novel, and yes, an adventuresome story with of import messages against tyranny and happily, fortunately in favour of striving against political oppression, but besides historically inaccurate and yep too inaccurate on a literature basis as well for me to recommend The Apple and the Arrow without some major reservations and caveats, specially to and for readers like myself who adore Schiller'due south Wilhelm Tell and consider his Wilhelm Tell as the bona fide, the true Wilhelm Tell of legend and maybe of history). ...more than
Both kids liked this book. Wonderful book that shows how Switzerland began, fighting against tyranny, and the love of God..krb 9/10/16
Look, I get it, people want to imagine that good little Christian children carry piously when unaccompanied by their parents. This was supposed to be taking place in the 1200'south in Switzerland but it reads how a 1950'southward parent would wish fo
I did not actually finish this. I just couldn't. It lost me when the 2 unaccompanied children stop and kneel at a cross at the side of the route as part of their routine after spending an afternoon practicing their marksmanship to delight dear sometime absent-minded begetter.Expect, I become it, people want to imagine that good niggling Christian children carry piously when unaccompanied by their parents. This was supposed to be taking place in the 1200'due south in Switzerland merely it reads how a 1950'southward parent would wish for their would-exist chantry male child to behave. I just actually, really don't similar unrealistic children in books.
Yeah, y'all could say that it was the 1950's AND the authors were trying to portray the 1200'south. However, back in 1902 Nesbit wrote a perfectly believable children's book chosen "5 Children and It" where the children have pretty typical attitudes to normal children everywhere.
People are people are people. The children of yesteryear weren't noble miniaturized adults. Since William Tell is a legend and folktale and nothing exists about him except what was written fully 200 years subsequently the upshot; well, I estimate I'thousand saying they could have had a scrap of fun with the fabric. Though, I volition say that the male child is such an insufferable, pious little bootlicker that I wouldn't particularly heed attempting to shoot an apple tree off the summit of his head either.
I was going to endeavour to read all the Newbery medal books; this book perfectly exemplifies why I've abased that endeavor. At present my goal is to Try all the Newbery medal books.
Would dearest to see someone tackle a William Tell book for children in a way that would actually be entertaining. I'm certain someone from Switzerland has already done information technology well, only probably isn't bachelor in English. :)
...more
Geography: Switzerland
Ages: seven+
Cleanliness: "Bl**dy" used to mean lots of blood. "Holy Mary" and "go to the devil" are said. Mentions a man who'south "daughter had suffered at the hands of one of Gessler'south soldiers." Mentions vino.
Whether it'southward history or legend, this is a wonderful story! Read information technology for the fiddling boy's nobility of character, as a New Year's Eve read or as a Swiss legend and information technology's people's fight for independence.Geography: Switzerland
Ages: 7+
Cleanliness: "Bl**dy" used to mean lots of blood. "Holy Mary" and "go to the devil" are said. Mentions a homo who's "girl had suffered at the hands of one of Gessler's soldiers." Mentions wine.
...more
Tell'due south story i
Do whatever American children learn nearly William Tell today? Do whatsoever Swiss children learn almost him? Very few, if any, I suspect. My children practise, but only because last twelvemonth I was reminded of William Tell by Ernst Jünger's "The Forest Passage," and and so I went and bought what few children'southward books are yet in print about the Swiss hero. Amid those was "The Apple and the Pointer," winner of the Newberry Medal in 1952, which I have just finished reading to my children, to their slap-up please.Tell's story is the core legend associated with the founding of the Former Swiss Confederacy, where around A.D. 1300 three communes (basically the cantons of today), Uri, Schwyz, and Unterwalden, agreed to human activity together for purposes of defense and merchandise. This was not the Mutual Market, a primarily economic organisation. Rather, the Swiss expected to accept to fight to maintain their political freedom, and they did. And similar most legends remembered through the ages, especially those suppressed by our ruling classes today (which most are), the Tell story is chock full of useful lessons for mod men and women, some of which are thrown into highlight by today's events.
The background history is a little complex, but in brusk at that fourth dimension the ultimate overlord of all what is at present Switzerland was the Holy Roman Emperor, though in practice day-to-mean solar day political control was unremarkably in the hands of a greater or lesser ducal family. The Habsburgs, the villains of the Tell story, were originally just another such Swiss ducal family—"Habsburg" was not the family name, but the name of their castle in the Swiss canton of Aargau, which, like the three original cantons of the Confederacy, adjoined Lake Lucerne. Ducal rule was not the just arrangement—sometimes the relevant lord was a powerful local abbot (this was true for long periods in Schwyz) and sometimes a town or canton enjoyed "imperial immediacy," directly dominion (very low-cal) by the Emperor, which in practice was, naturally, strongly resisted by the local dukes. For example, Emperor Frederick 2 granted Schwyz imperial immediacy in 1240, only the Habsburgs gradually accrued power there anyway—the Emperor was far away and had much else on his mind. By 1 method or another, past the finish of the thirteenth century the Habsburgs exercised immediate control over all 3 cantons, merely this was a control of short continuing—non sanctioned by custom, the real source of nearly medieval law, and not liked by the Swiss, used to hands-off dominion in their mountains and forests.
According to the Tell legend, Habsburg effrontery began the trouble. Rudolph of Habsburg died in 1290, and was succeeded by his son Albert, who decided to evidence the stiff-necked Swiss who was in charge. Albert sent a bailiff, or reeve, one Albrecht Gessler, to Altdorf, the main town of Uri, to administer the cantons claimed by the Habsburgs. Gessler set upwards a pole in the market, atop which he placed his hat, and required all passers-by to bow to the hat. This was a double humiliation, and intended as such, for not just was obeisance to a chapeau non something free men were accustomed to, only Gessler himself was a commoner, and not even entitled to the modest deference the Swiss might have offered a noble.
The story from hither is uncomplicated enough. William Tell was a huntsman of pocket-size means living in Uri. He took his son to market place, and Gessler'southward soldiers demanded he bow to the chapeau. He refused, and was arrested and taken to Gessler. The reeve knew of Tell'south reputation for marksmanship, and and then ordered that Tell shoot an apple tree off his son's head, or they would both be killed. Tell, seeing no choice, took ii crossbow bolts, put 1 in his chugalug and the other in his weapon, and successfully dissever the apple. Gessler, angry and no uncertainty suspecting the reason, demanded to know why Tell had put a second commodities in his belt. Tell refused to answer, other than saying information technology was a bowman'due south custom, so Gessler assured Tell he would non be executed if he answered. Whereupon Tell told Gessler that if he had struck his son, he would have immediately taken the second bolt and killed Gessler.
No surprise, this enraged Gessler. But he did not break his hope—rather, he assured Tell he would die in prison. Gessler's men took Tell in a boat, across Lake Lucerne, to the dungeon of Küssnacht. They never fabricated information technology—a storm blew up, and Tell, experienced on the h2o, was untied and told to steer the craft. He brought it to state—and leaped off, fleeing into the forest, while the gunkhole was carried by the waves back onto the lake. But Tell did non return abode. Instead, he lay in look for Gessler to either drown or to get to shore. He managed the latter, and with his men immediately proceeded to his castle—then Tell assassinated him from the shadows with his crossbow. This second half of the fable is frequently forgotten, when this tyrannicide is really the most important part of the legend—both the action itself, and that it began the forging of a new system, rather than being simply an attempt to turn back the clock, which is and can never be successful.
Thus began the Swiss war of rebellion against the Habsburgs, in which the key battles were Morgarten (1315) and Sempach (1386). In the latter, the Habsburg duke, Leopold III, was killed, allowing the Confederacy to expand. Today, with many twists and turns forth the way, the Swiss nonetheless live under a political system with external characteristics not that dissimilar, most notably a subsidiarity farthermost past modernistic standards, and the use of national referendums to decide of import questions. The Swiss are, or were until recently, free—not a libertarian liberty that exalts individual choice, but an ordered freedom.
The Apple and the Pointer views the fundamental events of the fable through the lens not simply of Tell, merely of his immediate family. The authors accept some liberties with the traditional legend, most notably casting Tell as an active participant in a conspiracy against Austrian tyranny prior to running afoul of Gessler'southward hat, whereas in the traditional version, he was an apolitical man radicalized by that event. No thing; the exact details of the revolt confronting the Habsburgs are long lost, and what matters is that the men of the 3 cantons agreed to fight, and did. They risked their lives, and won, for which their advantage was to chance their lives again and again, since equally the saying goes, freedom isn't free.
That's not to say the women didn't matter—every bit e'er in the West, they mattered a great bargain, they just didn't pretend to be men, equally women are told today they must. One key benefit of this book as a children'southward book is that information technology depicts, and instructs children in, proper roles for men and women, those based on reality and resulting in a healthy society. The story offered is not the dizzy fantasy we would get if the book were written today, where Tell's daughter would have the best crossbow skills in the county, spend her days humiliating boys with her superior skills in every physical endeavor, and exist solely responsible for killing Gessler, shrieking "Girl Power!", while her father cowered in fright at abode. In this volume, rather, Tell'south wife, Hedwig, takes counsel with her married man, balances and smooths the edges off the defects that are inherent in masculinity (as he balances the defects that are inherent in femininity), and is an active participant, in a wholly realistic way, in the Swiss fight for independence, while never lifting a weapon or leaving her village. That's the mode a society should work, and mostly did piece of work, until nosotros were fed infinite amounts of lying propaganda well-nigh the past and sold a bill of goods about relationships betwixt men and women, resulting in today'south pernicious chaos, pleasing and benefiting neither sex, that afflicts men and women today at all stages of their lives.
So I highly recommend this book. Even for adults, it'due south a quick introduction to the Tell story, worth having in these days when information technology is more often than not forgotten, or rather suppressed for the hero'due south supposedly retrograde nature, for daring to accurately reflect reality and celebrate virtues that our masters deny are virtues. It's a reminder of when awards such as the Newberry Medal, awarded by the American Library Association, went to worthy books. Today, the ALA is overtly racist and celebrates diverse perversions, and, inevitably, its awards don't reflect merit, but its political priorities and its desire to indoctrinate children into its divisive credo. You tin can be certain no book given a medal today focuses on, or even shows, a potent nuclear family, or shows men doing masculine things while women do feminine things. At present, the Newberry Medal's master do good is to prove a book to avoid. Schools, of course, eagerly employ such guides, and similar collections that have gone full Left, such equally Scholastic, to cull books to indoctrinate children. For example, my children'due south school proudly displayed, before the Wuhan virus close their doors, the covers of iv books all grades under fifth must use to brainwash children. Two were racist and that was their master point. I historic homosexual penguins. To be fair, the fourth was mostly virtually kindness, although with racist overtones and encouraging an attitude of helplessness and handouts in tough economical straits. Needless to say, no volume was written more than ten years ago, or was in any way a classic story, or volition exist remembered ten years from now.
It's non just the Newberry Medal that has gone downhill. The Swiss take, too, though it took nearly vii hundred years. I'g not an skillful on Swiss politics, just I retrieve much of the recent plough to the Left winning national referendums is due to the dying out of the rural Swiss and their replacement with (besides dying out, but more slowly) effete city dwellers who are mere carbon copies of the stop-stage Eu-loving drones of Germany. In recent years, for example, the Swiss take sharply express the correct to go on firearms (long correctly deemed necessary to maintain a free society) and imposed "hate speech" laws (always but ever used to suppress conservatives), among other stupidities. Today, Tell'south target wouldn't be a strange overlord, but the men of his own country who have stripped its people of their freedoms and bow to strange ideological domination. True, in Switzerland as in other European countries, a party devoted to the state's original ideals continues to gain power, violently attacked using the usual totalitarian tricks of the ruling form, and the event is ultimately in doubt (more so now with the Chinese virus spreading chaos in Europe, although the pansified global reaction to the pandemic gives more crusade for pessimism than promise most the future).
I take talked elsewhere at length almost rebellion and tyrannicide, so I will non specifically address the morality of Tell's actions (brusk version: they're awesome). Nor will I talk again virtually Ernst Jünger'south casting of Tell equally the original "wood rebel," which is a fascinating analysis very much worth reading. It interests me, too, only I will not talk today virtually, how the Tell legend illustrates the radicalization of men in the face of injustice—in essence, how and why men react to injustice past taking huge risks to inflict violence on their oppressors achieve a goal of which the risk-taker has no legitimate expectation of success and when he will almost certainly lose his own life. Not long ago, this was ane of the nearly common storylines, across cultures—that men will oftentimes value justice far more than their own lives. But I will save that for some other time.
Instead, let'south talk current events, that on which everyone is forced to focus. The Chinese virus has highlighted that in the West today the dominant ethos is that every person should value nigh of all his own life, at any price that may exist imposed on others or on broader society. This is fundamentally a form of cowardice, just less judgmentally (not that in that location's annihilation at all wrong with judging others), it is a form of societal feminization, since protection is a core characteristic of women, in their nature. We run across this in the global reaction to the Wuhan virus, which has sharply exposed many things, merely in this context it has exposed how deep into the West the drastic desire for prophylactic, at all costs but granted and directed by others stronger than ourselves, has choked us. Its manifestation in this moment is that rather than weighing risks and rewards, and choosing to bear burdens to achieve goals, the vast majority of people accept, and even seek out, the most exaggerated worst-instance scenarios every bit reality, and human action on the basis of reducing risk as close to nil equally possible. Anybody knows the internet has turned most of us into hypochondriacs, but perchance information technology's not WebMD that has washed that, simply our ain flaccidity and the simpering weakness of our "leaders."
In that location is picayune doubt at this betoken that the death charge per unit from the virus amongst the vast majority of people is very low. The obvious respond is to protect those actually at run a risk, or to permit them protect themselves if they choose, and permit everyone else get on with their lives, taking reasonable precautions. Even so in that location is no logical give-and-take, and any information that does not support the dominant narrative of overprotective panic is swiftly censored or retentiveness-holed. Also pervading the hysteria is a potent chemical element of wanting to avoid "stigma" by pretending that everyone is similarly situated; the desire to non stigmatize others or encounter them stigmatized is a feminine trait. And to the extent that activity, rather than passivity, is asked for by those in charge, it is second-club feminine actions, like initiatives for "kindness," effectually which a municipality in my area has launched a massive campaign, consummate with plenty of colored chalk drawings on local driveways. That'll show the virus!
Anybody is told he must enter his authorities-provided mental cocoon and hold shut his regime-issued teddy bear, and await for it all to be over. He complies, for he is no William Tell or forest insubordinate, even though there is no visible path for a return to normalcy other than past simply suffering for a short, precipitous period, while doing our best to protect and help those actually at meaning risk. That truth is ignored and painted, for no specified reason, as evil. Instead, nosotros take and cower to the demands of legions of Karens, who lecture u.s. that all that matters is following "the rules," whatever those are today, whomever they are issued past, and whether or not they brand any sense. And in truth, virtually of those always-irresolute rules are the commands of the fearful women who run governments, either directly as political leaders, who may have been an adequate choice to coddle a weak just stable club, but were the incorrect pick for a crisis, or who have foolishly been put in charge of our councils, rather than sent to nurse the ill.
Instead of interim with a forthright, decisive . . . [Review completes as first comment.]
...more
In that location is noticeably more suspense to this volume than in most other Newbery Honor recipients from the early 1950s. About the showtime of the story, as Walter listens from his bedchamber to the heated chat betwixt his mother and male parent about the electric current state of their land, and his mother cautions his father confronting stirring upwardly any more problem, one can imagine the possibility of a government soldier riding up at any fourth dimension to bring danger to the Tell'southward door. The dark night could hide whatsoever sort of lurking conspirator working for Gessler, listening in for a selection bit of secret data that could put Walter's father and the rest of his family in mortal jeopardy. Walter worries nigh his father in this new tyrannical government state run by the despised Gessler, but it turns out that he won't take to worry from distant. Walter is going to be correct in the centre of the activeness as matters turn from bleak to fifty-fifty bleaker, and he is compelled to put his life in the easily of his father to an extent that few children will ever exist required to match.
The Apple and the Arrow is an fantabulous story, but I'd have to say that what stands out best about information technology is the mode that Walter handles the apple-shooting incident. His total conviction in the human he calls father never wavers for an instant. He has a "bring it on" attitude well-nigh the whole ruthless test, and nether the circumstances it'due south quite obvious that nothing at all near his response was an empty evidence. He was risking his life by standing directly beneath the trajectory of his father'south arrow, still Walter never flinched considering he knew in his heart that in that location was no style his father was going to miss this shot. It was impossible that his male parent would ever kill him, and and so there was no reason for fright of the damage that the arrow could potentially cause. The horrified spectators were watching a struggle for life or decease that would rest with unbearable precariousness on a razor'southward thin border; Walter, gazing out at his father from beneath the piece of fruit bestowed upon his head, was watching no such struggle. To him, he had simply been given the all-time seat in the house to observe what would undoubtedly be his father'south greatest triumph. Who can assist simply exist shaken by such an instance of deep and utterly unwavering faith?
So while The Apple and the Arrow on the surface is a story nearly political oppression and the strength of a free people to redeclare their own freedom when it is threatened, I run across it more every bit the celebration of a repose young hero who did more than for his country's revolution by standing in one place and not moving than most others accomplished by way of the sword. Ultimately, it was the stirring show of the male child'southward absolute faith that galvanized his countrymen to take upwards their part of the assuming commonage resolve necessary to overthrow Gessler's oppressive government and earn back for themselves the freedom that had been theirs by birth for so many centuries. But in many respects information technology all started with ane boy, who demonstrated his own power past believing wholeheartedly in the ability of another. It has always been and always will be hard to defeat strong faith, because when 1 truly is possessed of it, victory is never impossible.
I like this volume very much. Mary and Conrad Buff ever work together nicely as an author/illustrator combo, but The Apple and the Arrow is hands their best work that I've read. There's a good chance that I would give it the full three stars.
...more
The story follows a small male child and his famous and brave begetter William Tell. Nosotros are introduced to our chief grapheme equally they are outside and being outside is most of the story. We see how William Tell and his men go well-nigh planning a revolution and are thwarted at showtime past evil men and and then triumph over that. The revolution happens and nosotros see the beginning of a war and the pivotal points that started this uprising from his son, Walter. A chief signal of the story is when William shoots an apple from Walter's caput.
...more than
At that place is a heavy revolutionary message akin to the fervor of the American Revolution, only at a smaller scale and in the late 1200'south. But a tale of fighting against tyranny is timeless. In this tale we see the desire to be rid of a new political and majestic tyranny, while trying to proceed your family condom. Tell is a noble effigy, balancing his Cosmic faith with his family's safety, as well as his desire for freedom and yea This volume tells the legend of William Tell and the offset of Switzerland.
At that place is a heavy revolutionary message akin to the fervor of the American Revolution, merely at a smaller calibration and in the tardily 1200'south. But a tale of fighting confronting tyranny is timeless. In this tale nosotros see the desire to be rid of a new political and royal tyranny, while trying to keep your family safety. Tell is a noble figure, balancing his Catholic faith with his family's safety, every bit well equally his desire for freedom and yearning for vengeance.
⚠️ Parental Warnings ⚠️
Some suspense and non-graphic deaths.
Null inappropriate.
I picked it upwardly off the shelf one evening and read it in an hr or so to my hubby and my eight year sometime son. Information technology was a perfect for what it was. A short uplifting story virtually a legend of a truly amazing homo and how Switzerland gained its independence.
It'southward pages are rich with tales of integrity, morals, strength, faith, liberty, and backbone.
At This footling jewel has been sitting on my shelf for quite awhile at present. I saw it at a 2d manus store and, remembering people'due south comments about it, purchased it.
I picked information technology up off the shelf ane evening and read information technology in an hour or so to my hubby and my 8 year old son. Information technology was a perfect for what information technology was. A short uplifting story nigh a legend of a truly amazing man and how Switzerland gained its independence.
It's pages are rich with tales of integrity, morals, strength, organized religion, freedom, and courage.
At one point Walter is sitting at his mothers human knee. She teaches him something unproblematic and even so so profound, she says: "All will fight as 1 nation. All will die together also, if information technology ever comes to that." I expect at the things going on in our nation and they seem so divisive. There is power in staying United. Hedwig is a wise woman to recognize this and so are the people in her world.
William teaches us another, maybe more profound, lesson when in the town square, he is told to bow before a hat waving on a flag pole. He is ordered to and he refuses, logically explaining that he will not bow downward to a matter of rags. 'Next thing yous'll command usa to bow down before you, you bullies.' 'I will bow only to those more truly noble than I.... A hat is goose egg to worship.'
The lesson here is what he teaches us. The hat is a distraction and a ways to a more controlling stop. Information technology'due south nada but a way to see how far they can push the people. That is happening so much more magnified correct at present in my country. The powers that be are throwing then many distractions at us and we are being distracted past them alright. In the hateful fourth dimension they are using those distraction to divide the states--considering we are letting them and what'south worse while we are letting them distract united states of america they are busy passing laws that seem to 'ready' the problems but in fact are actually destroying the Founding documents that make our country free.
And so comes Walter! Walter teaches us the well-nigh powerful of all the lessons contained in this book. The ability of faith! I heard a comment just today that faith and fear cannot cohabitate. When the fourth dimension comes for William to shoot the apple tree off Walters head Walter with consummate organized religion and confidence tells his father to do it. And then he adds: 'Shoot, Father, shoot. I am non afraid. God is watching over us.' And this brought back his fathers courage.
As the story concludes Walter has solidified through the example of his mother and begetter that 'man lives by faith, and that faith tin can be stronger than fear.'
I then hope that we tin can grasp the concept of these simple withal profound lessons and that we can, similar William, be 'peaceful' men simply I also hope that we, again like William, will always 'be dauntless men' and 'risk all we have for a belief.' I hope we can know what Walter knew: Man lives past faith and faith tin be stronger than fearfulness! ...more
Premise/plot: Walter Tell loves his father William very much. He's proud to be his son, the son of ane of the best bowmen ever. And he'due south a bit proud that he'south old enough and responsible plenty to concur such important secrets, secrets that could endanger the lives of his father and other men of the community of Uri. You see, come New Yr's Day, the
First sentence: "Missed it again. Go and find the arrow, Rudi, volition you lot? It cruel near that old rotten log over there--the 1 with the big hole in information technology."Premise/plot: Walter Tell loves his father William very much. He'southward proud to be his son, the son of one of the best bowmen ever. And he's a bit proud that he's old enough and responsible enough to hold such important secrets, secrets that could endanger the lives of his male parent and other men of the community of Uri. You see, come up New year's day'south Day, the men are planning to revolt against the Austrians. The year is 1291. And the nation of Switzerland is a mere idea in the minds of men and women who long for freedom.
My thoughts: I'd heard a tiny bit about William Tell earlier. (The shooting an apple off his son'south head affair.) I liked this i so much more than I thought I would. It is a Newbery Accolade book from the 1950s. (So many Newbery winners and honors are set in medieval times.) I liked the faith elements in this one. So little is said nearly God and about prayer.
Favorite quotes:
War means starvation and decease, not only for soldiers, but for women and children as well. War ever means that. (17)
Dearest Lord, Father of all men, look down upon us this great dark. Be with the states when the bells ring, when the signal fires burn. Assist u.s.a. throw from our shoulders the yoke of the tyrant. But, proficient Lord, let no blood flow this night in the country of Uri. Even in this, our greatest hour, assist united states of america to call up that all men, even evil men, are our brothers. Go on our hearts pure, our arms strong. For the Virgin's sake. Amen."(74)
Now he knew why his mother had wished him to be here on this nighttime of nights. He felt information technology all dimly, just he felt it even so. He knew what the wise have e'er known, that men lives by religion, and that faith tin be stronger than fright.(76)...more
I actually liked this book and it was piece of cake to read and I recommend thi
The Apple tree And The Arrow was a book that I actually was practiced. In the begging Walter was shooting arrows and his male parent came back belatedly at night and told him the he would have him to Aldouf. In the center Walter asked his father to tell the story of when he was younger and how he ran away course the solders. At the end Walter and his brother went to a fire belatedly at night and Walter had to carry his brother home and they all fell comatose.I really liked this book and information technology was easy to read and I recommend this book to a reader that likes to have a curt story to read.
...more
(Deplorable if these are spoilers for you, but it is a legend that's 700
The legend of William Tell! I'd heard that name but didn't actually know the deets virtually why he was famous. Apparently he refused to bow downward to a hat. (I'm withal laughing at this.) So the evil governor forced him to shoot an pointer off his child's caput (which he did with aplomb!) and and then arrested him. They took him across dangerous seas and William Tell had to steer the boat and eventually he escaped and shot the evil governor.(Sorry if these are spoilers for you, but it is a legend that's 700 years old, so I feel that's passed the statute of limitations on spoilers.)
...more
The ultimate betoken here is that it's oftentimes easier to live with the trouble than to confront information technology. Other people in the William Tell story chose to genuflect earlier the hat considering that was easier than beingness hassled by the soldiers. William Tell refused, and aye, that meant he had a fight on his hands, ane that could take cost the life of his son. In today's world, it's certainly bad plenty when soulless corporations also cooperate with oppression, in the pursuit of curt-term profits. But individuals also play forth. No doubt many have been taught to believe the narrative, merely reciting information technology also enhances their social standing. On the other manus, not playing along can cost one in terms of employment (it did me, one time; I've since learned to seize with teeth my natural language). One'southward car might be keyed (mine was). Someone more prominent than I might also experience doxxing.
No, it'south much easier—and safer—to permit the tyrants have their way with our society, right?
In that context, William Tell remains a true hero.
...more than
fifth-6th course reading level
This volume is a great read for young readers or anyone looking for enjoyment in traditional literature. Information technology tells the story of the legend of a man named William Tell. This is told from the viewpoint of William'due south son and is set around a historical and political framework of Switzerland. I loved this book considering of the style that information technology uses a traditional literature aspect of story telling with a legend of a human in order to convey some pretty powerful mess Traditional Literature
5th-6th grade reading level
This book is a great read for young readers or anyone looking for enjoyment in traditional literature. It tells the story of the legend of a human being named William Tell. This is told from the viewpoint of William'south son and is set effectually a historical and political framework of Switzerland. I loved this book because of the way that it uses a traditional literature aspect of story telling with a legend of a man in order to convey some pretty powerful messages and to foster potent themes in the book. These themes include bravery, motivation, willpower, determination, and faith in others. Information technology is a fun and engaging book for readers, merely it also is great for fostering these themes in the lives of immature readers who may connect personally with the characters. For me, it shared with me a lot about being brave even in dangerous situations, even though that looks unlike today than it did back then. ...more
Genre: Historical Fiction
Newberry Honour Book
I liked this book because it is told from the son Walter'southward point of view. This book had me sitting on the edge of my seat not wanting to put information technology down considering I was so nervous nearly what was going to happen when Walter puts his trust in his father to do what he does. Nonetheless, the storyline of this volume is intriguing and the author develops a good theme within the text. I would recommend this book to young readers because information technology is a Newberry Honor Grades- 3-viii
Genre: Historical Fiction
Newberry Honor Book
I liked this volume because it is told from the son Walter's point of view. This book had me sitting on the edge of my seat not wanting to put it downward because I was so nervous virtually what was going to happen when Walter puts his trust in his begetter to do what he does. Nonetheless, the storyline of this book is intriguing and the writer develops a good theme within the text. I would recommend this book to young readers because it is a Newberry Accolade Volume and is based on the fight for freedom by the Swiss people. ...more than
Grade Level: 2-4
This volume just didn't interest me very much. I thought the folk tale was interesting and I enjoyed the pictures, but overall, it just wasn't for me. I did enjoy that this story gave a perspective on a time in history that is not oftentimes written about. Information technology was nice to read almost something unlike. I as well know this story could be popular in a classroom among students interested in medieval times. I will definitely proceed this in listen for those students, but f
Genre: Historical FictionClass Level: 2-4
This book merely didn't interest me very much. I thought the folk tale was interesting and I enjoyed the pictures, but overall, it just wasn't for me. I did savour that this story gave a perspective on a time in history that is not ofttimes written almost. Information technology was dainty to read about something different. I also know this story could be popular in a classroom amid students interested in medieval times. I will definitely keep this in mind for those students, only for me, I simply couldn't get into this story.
...more than
News & Interviews
Welcome back. Simply a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account.
The Apple And The Arrow,
Source: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1077704.The_Apple_and_the_Arrow
Posted by: mossstrater.blogspot.com
0 Response to "The Apple And The Arrow"
Post a Comment